Another trainer loses his mind as May approaches

[Indian Charlie]

An article in the DRF is stating that Catalano is giving serious consideration to the Oaks for Dreaming of Anna, because she is training so well.

http://www.drf.com/news/article/84319.html

[Unstable]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

An article in the DRF is stating that Catalano is giving serious consideration to the Oaks for Dreaming of Anna, because she is training so well.

http://www.drf.com/news/article/84319.html

At least they're not considering entering her in the Derby... yet.

[blackthroatedwind]

It might be a little unfair to blame the trainer on this one.

Wouldn't the Ashland, a $500K Grade 1 on polytrack, have been the right spot? One has to wonder why she missed that race and therefore how she could be ready for the Oaks.

It looks more and more likely she will never win again. Not all that surprising.

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

It might be a little unfair to blame the trainer on this one.

Wouldn't the Ashland, a $500K Grade 1 on polytrack, have been the right spot? One has to wonder why she missed that race and therefore how she could be ready for the Oaks.

It looks more and more likely she will never win again. Not all that surprising.

maybe. however, i liked the old fashioned trainers that used to put their foot down when an owner was about to try something stupid. ultimately, in my eyes, the trainer should be responsible for stupid moves like this. is he that afraid that owner will change trainers?

i also think a race over poly would have been a better spot, since she's training so marvelously on it. then again, she has speed, so maybe dirt is the better option. if they really had half a clue, they'd try running her on turf.

who knows, she might even like it!

[The Indomitable DrugS]

She ran on turf last time out.

[Indian Charlie]

my mistake drugS. the gulfstream turf is pretty ridiculous, so i dont pay much attention to races on that surface.

retire her.

[GPK]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

maybe. however, i liked the old fashioned trainers that used to put their foot down when an owner was about to try something stupid. ultimately, in my eyes, the trainer should be responsible for stupid moves like this. is he that afraid that owner will change trainers?

i also think a race over poly would have been a better spot, since she's training so marvelously on it. then again, she has speed, so maybe dirt is the better option. if they really had half a clue, they'd try running her on turf.

who knows, she might even like it!

The Summer Stakes she won at Woodbine last year was on grass...as was the Tippet Stakes she won at Colonial.

[Hickory Hill Hoff]

She was the most "overrated" 2 year old filly champion of all time...Rags to Riches would eat her alive now

[JJP]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

is he that afraid that owner will change trainers?

Very possible. He's done it before and will likely do it again. Calabrese has a massive ego.

[Cannon Shell]

Originally Posted by Indian Charlie

maybe. however, i liked the old fashioned trainers that used to put their foot down when an owner was about to try something stupid. ultimately, in my eyes, the trainer should be responsible for stupid moves like this. is he that afraid that owner will change trainers?

Owners often change trainers for much more trivial matters than being told that they are stupid. There are very few trainers that have the luxury of being able to tell the owner not to do someting stupid and keep their horses.

[ELA]

Private trainer, big owner, and they've been married and divorced and married again -- more than once, LOL. I often question who is calling what shot in many cases -- jock, spot, etc.

From what I hear, Catalano is going public, maybe full blown, and Calabrese is moving some of the soldiers around, or just riding out what he has and restocking with a few others. Maybe true, maybe not. Not really sure.

Eric

[jman5581]

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell

Owners often change trainers for much more trivial matters than being told that they are stupid. There are very few trainers that have the luxury of being able to tell the owner not to do someting stupid and keep their horses.

Chuck, put Sumwon in the Oaks, pronto!

I've polled the partners (didn't you know?)... skip Saturday. Go straight to the Oaks. No lip or we'll find someone who will

[disappearingdan_akaplaya]

first of all wayne wouldnt lose his mind, hes very sharp and makes alotta levings bad claims look good. i guess catman can do no good in anyones eyes. we had sickos last year here at hawthorne including some backside people rooting against them down the lane in the BC, now some are questioning him. i wouldnt call her the most overrated 2yo filly champ of all time, some horses mature alot more between ages 2 and 3

[PPerfectfan]

Yeah I saw this,,,, crazy. I dont think they know what to do with her at all.

[blackthroatedwind]

Horses that run in major races as after thoughts very rarely do well. Add that to the fact that she's not that good and you have a serious also ran.

[ArlJim78]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

Horses that run in major races as after thoughts very rarely do well. Add that to the fact that she's not that good and you have a serious also ran.

this is like a handicapping maxim that I have found to be almost always solid.

I just think its tough to win a huge major race, based on a last minute decision because you are going up against others who have been targeting the same race dilligently for months and will naturally be more prepared.