Curlin and Big Brown...JUST SAY NO!

[richard burch]

In todays NY Daily News a match race between the 2 horses is being talked about after the Breeders Cup. Very Stupid.

Isn't this a dangerous proposition? Why would you risk your horses health to satisfy an ego trip? It would be much better and safer to see them race in a 6+ horse field against other good horses. Match races do not show who is the "better" horse because it is not normal race conditions. It just puts more stress on the horse and jockey to win at all costs.

I will appeal to Jess Jackson because he seems to be the more rational of the two participants. Please don't take Dutrows bait. The Jackson family certainly doesn't need the money. I hope he remembers Ruffian.

[blackthroatedwind]

Why exactly is a match race more risky than any race? I don't get it.

[CSC]

A match race didn't hurt Seabiscuit or War Admiral, nor did it hurt the game. I can't understand why anyone who loves horseracing or sporting events would be against this idea. I just find it hard to believe it will happen.

[slotdirt]

Just because Ruffian went down in a match race doesn't mean match races are altogether bad. Should we stop running the Preakness, Derby, Breeders Cup Distaff, CompUSA Dixie, or $7500 claimers on a Wednesday at Timonium, because horses have all broken down in those races in recent years as well.

[VOL JACK]

Originally Posted by richard burch

In todays NY Daily News a match race between the 2 horses is being talked about after the Breeders Cup. Very Stupid.

Isn't this a dangerous proposition? Why would you risk your horses health to satisfy an ego trip? It would be much better and safer to see them race in a 6+ horse field against other good horses. Match races do not show who is the "better" horse because it is not normal race conditions. It just puts more stress on the horse and jockey to win at all costs.

I will appeal to Jess Jackson because he seems to be the more rational of the two participants. Please don't take Dutrows bait. The Jackson family certainly doesn't need the money. I hope he remembers Ruffian.

Dude, are you serious? Its like saying Kobe and Lebron shouldnt play a game of 1 on 1 because they are more likely to get hurt, than if they played in a team setting.
There are match races that take place everyday at every track, There just happens to be other horses on the track.

LIE AH just wants a match race because they know its there only shot to beat the champ.

[CSC]

No one is more sad than I when any horse breaks down, however I hope this doesn't sound too esoteric.... I'm sure god didn't create horses with the intention of them being put in a petting zoo...they have to do what they were created for.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by richard burch

I hope he remembers Ruffian.

They shouldn't have it on a dirt surface either. Doesn't anyone remember Barbaro?

[richard burch]

disregarding injuries, quite frankly there is little drama in a match race. there are no pace setters, no stalkers and no closers. certain horses need the right scenerios and fractions to win. i dont believe it would show who the superior horse is, so why do it?

I am not saying "don't race".

I am saying "race under normal conditions".

[richard burch]

Originally Posted by VOL JACK

Dude, are you serious? Its like saying Kobe and Lebron shouldnt play a game of 1 on 1 because they are more likely to get hurt, than if they played in a team setting.
There are match races that take place everyday at every track, There just happens to be other horses on the track.

LIE AH just wants a match race because they know its there only shot to beat the champ.

the difference is that if lebron breaks his ankle they dont euthanize him....DUDE!

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by richard burch

I am saying "race under normal conditions".

Big Brown obviously gains a tactical advantage if the meeting comes in the form of a match race. He gets to make his own pace unpressured

I'd take a healthy Monterry Jazz or Commentator and the odds over both horses in a match race.

[richard burch]

Originally Posted by The Indomitable DrugS

They shouldn't have it on a dirt surface either. Doesn't anyone remember Barbaro?

yes i remember...his picture is next to my name.

[SCUDSBROTHER]

If you really have your horse ready, then why would you only want to beat one horse(and in a race that will never be held again.) Wouldn't you just race in the biggest races you can find? A great horse should be able to beat good horses on any surface (even if he just tolerates the surface.) If he can't, then he is just another good horse.

[The Indomitable DrugS]

Originally Posted by SCUDSBROTHER

A great horse should be able to beat good horses on any surface (even if he just tolerates the surface.) If he can't, then he is just another good horse.

An ordinary horse should be able to beat mediocre horses on any surface. If he can't, then he is just another Yankee Bravo.

[mes5107]

Originally Posted by richard burch

the difference is that if lebron breaks his ankle they dont euthanize him....DUDE!

I think he is saying that a match race presents no more probability of injury than a race with a larger field. Whether or not a horse has a catosrophic injury in a match race or a race with a full field, he will still be euthanized.

[Indian Charlie]

While match races are a clear danger to the two horses in the race, I think people are missing what's really dangerous for a horse.

That's when they run by themselves, in workouts. There are workout fatalities on a daily basis. These are what should have a stop put to them.

[cakes44]

Put a stop to workouts?

[Indian Charlie]

Originally Posted by cakes44

Put a stop to workouts?

END THEM NOW!

[richard burch]

Originally Posted by SCUDSBROTHER

If you really have your horse ready, then why would you only want to beat one horse(and in a race that will never be held again.) Wouldn't you just race in the biggest races you can find? A great horse should be able to beat good horses on any surface (even if he just tolerates the surface.) If he can't, then he is just another good horse.

nice reply...finally, someone who understands.

[Bobby Fischer]

***THOROUGHBRED CHAMPIONSHIP!***

***MATCH RACE OF THE CENTURY***


CURLIN
vs.
BIG BROWN

SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 1, 2008
Gulfstream Park Racetrack
LIVE ON PAY-PER-VIEW
9:00PM ET/ 6:00PM PT


To wager on this event sign up now on MATCHRACE.COM.
5% Rebate on all losses. No fees.
50+ available tracks DAILY.

BUDWEISER
DODGE
KENTUCKY FRIED CHICKEN
TACO BELL
MATCHRACE.COM

Originally Posted by richard burch

nice reply...finally, someone who understands.

[richard burch]

Originally Posted by Bobby Fischer

***THOROUGHBRED CHAMPIONSHIP!***

***MATCH RACE OF THE CENTURY***


CURLIN
vs.
BIG BROWN

SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 1, 2008
Gulfstream Park Racetrack
LIVE ON PAY-PER-VIEW
9:00PM ET/ 6:00PM PT


To wager on this event sign up now on MATCHRACE.COM.
5% Rebate on all losses. No fees.
50+ available tracks DAILY.

BUDWEISER
DODGE
KENTUCKY FRIED CHICKEN
TACO BELL
MATCHRACE.COM

i want a $1 exacta box.