Idol top 12...my thoughts

[somerfrost]

Well, some things went as I thought, Sanjaya continues to be an embarrassment, the boys as a unit are far beneath the girls and the top girls can be stars! I'd rank this week's performances this way:
12) Sanjaya...please get this person off the show
11) Brandon...yep, a backup singer
10) Phil...high notes are ok, anything else is ...well, Sanjaya-like
9) Chris R....shows nothing
8) Chris S...what was he thinking???
7) Haley...I was prepared to rank her with Sanjaya but I agree with Simon...there was something there tonight that shown through the pitch mistakes and the memory lapse!
6) Gina...not her best
5) Stephanie...mistake in arrangement
4) Blake...well, at least he's different!
3) Jordin...wow, great job!
2) LaKisha...showed something tonight by not over-singing, another great performance
1) Melinda...yes, she brought tears to my eyes...a fantastic performance...again!