Scat Daddy or Circular Quay?

Originally Posted by Cunningham Racing

We'll see when they go two turns...I have already acknowledged that CQ won the Hopeful and didn't take anything away from his perfromance and I went a step further by stating that he would probbably win the Champagne if entered - BUT, I still believe Scat Daddy will be better around two turns.....

Thats a fair statement. And i can see how someone might like Scat Daddy's higher early speed and more evenly paced style to suit two turns.
So why not just state it like that in the first place and save 90 posts worth of arguing Joel?