2011-2012 NHL playoff thread. - Page 33

pgiaco · #**641** 06-27-2012, 05:36 PM

I'm having a hard time seeing Mats Sundin in the HOF...I guess he did turn Alexei Ponikarovsky into a 25 goal scorer, but really?

Danzig · #**642** 06-27-2012, 05:48 PM

damndamndamn

our loss is calgary's gain, dennis wideman to the flames.

Bigsmc · #**643** 06-28-2012, 05:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by slotdirt

Not a knock, Andreychuck just played freaking forever (or so it seemed). Very Gary Roberts-like.

I hope you're not making an argument that Andreychuck was a better player than Shanahan. Andreychuck needed over 100 more games to net 16 fewer goals. I'm not sure they're even comparable.

I don't argue, I leave that to the the regulars in the Political threads. I was asking a question, because it seemed to me they both played forever. Just throwing another name out that may compare to the guys that got in.

slotdirt · #**644** 06-28-2012, 09:06 AM

Andreychuck should probably get in someday, but the one spot where I think he fails is that he was never really one of the best players on the ice in any given season. I think that one can say that for Sundin, 100 percent for Bure when he was healthy, and definitely Sakic.

Shanahan had 12 different seasons with 30+ goals and 19 (!!!!) seasons with 20+ goals. Pretty incredible longevity.

-BT- · #**645** 06-28-2012, 11:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaTH716

Shanny not being elected to the HOF is almost as mind boggling and embarrassing as some of his rulings this past playoff season.

ding ding.... i said he was left off the ballot for how pussified he's making hockey these days.
not sure why people are getting their panties in a bunch, they guy will get in. I have no problem with this years class....if i had to cull one out it would be Sundin

-bt-

-BT- · #**646** 06-28-2012, 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig

damndamndamn

our loss is calgary's gain, dennis wideman to the flames.

i would be willing to help him pack. The guy was a defensive liability, and his points, even for a defensemen, didn't reflect his overall game, ala 2 years ago when Jeff Shultz led the world in +/-.

trading picks/players for rights to players you have no intention of signing is like found money IMO... and 5M+ per for that guy is a HUGE over payment, we already have one of those anyways... Mike Green

-bt-