My Eclipse Ballot

[Danzig]

Originally Posted by Kasept

You just said McCarron did it 23 years ago... so it's not unique. What Stevens has done is an unprecedented feat of athletic prowess. The only parallel I can think of immediately is Gordie Howe taking regular shifts in the NHL at 50+.

i think stevens is deserving. every year, you'll obviously have a jock with the most wins, and a jock with most money won. so, the reward for most money won, is a good bit of money.

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by iamthelurker

I'll say it again.... the first rider to lead the nation in wins and earnings in 23 years. That's the unique accomplishment here.

Ya know, college boy, that it isn't unique if it's happened before. Plus, 33 years not 23.

Did you really graduate?

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by Kasept

Delving further into other categories, some more bizarre omissions from printed PP's sent to voters? Animal Kingdom, Sweet Lulu, Streaming...

Animal Kingdom finished 2nd in his one US race. If he was an "omission" then surely there were MANY others.

[freddymo]

Originally Posted by Kasept

As part of the balloting process, was shocked that Authenticity was somehow omitted from PP's sent to voters for Older Filly/Mare. She banked $883k in '13 earnings, 2nd to Royal Delta's $1.1MM. There were very few real candidates in the division and yet Funny Proposition -- a Fleur Dis Lis winner her lone graded stake start -- makes the list while 9/3-4-2 Authenticity doesn't. All Authenticity did was win the La Troienne and Shuvee and hit the board in all 4 of her G1 appearences: 3rd BC Distaff, 2nd Zenyatta, 2nd Personal Ensign, 2nd Ogden Phipps.

Along with Royal Delta and Funny Proposition on the list, the other stalwarts offered for your consideration were Byrama, Joyful Victory, Lady of Fifty, On Fire Baby and Tiz Miz Sue. It's a glaring mistake and not the only oversight...

Smells of anti satishism

[Kasept]

Originally Posted by freddymo

Smells of anti satishism

Interesting you say that Fred because it popped into my head at first too. However, research into the situation with those most in the know brought out reality of simply a poor, sloppy execution of assembling the info.

[iamthelurker]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

Ya know, college boy, that it isn't unique if it's happened before. Plus, 33 years not 23.

Did you really graduate?

Love you too. Surprised you would agree it should go to Stevens. You are right though a typo and some poor word usage are all the more reason to question whether I actually got my degree. If I had said Castellano's rare accomplishment would you still of jumped at the chance to point out my age? I'm supposed to run away and hide now right? That's no fun.

I am not saying what Stevens has done this year should go without praise but there are more deserving candidates for the award. The year Mike Smith had at 48 years old was just as good if not better than Stevens.

All starts

Smith - 422 84 64 45 $13,797,517 $32,696 20%
Stevens - 383 69 59 58 $11,910,748 $31,099 18%

Stakes

Smith - 155 34 24 18 $11,309,528 $72,965 22%
Stevens - 132 24 19 15 $9,513,509 $72,072 18%

Graded Stakes

Smith - 116 28 16 12 $10,718,963 $92,405 24%
Stevens - 93 18 10 9 $8,856,303 $95,229 19%

Each won a Triple Crown race. Smith won three breeders cup albeit of lesser prestige than Stevens Distaff and Classic. Gary is not the only old guy still getting it done.

The sheer volume of Castellano's accomplishments this year in my mind surpasses a great story and comeback from an older rider. The fact a rider can lead the nation in wins based out of the toughest place to win races in the US is remarkable.

[blackthroatedwind]

I would give it to Javy.

I think Gary deserves special recognition.

[iamthelurker]

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind

I would give it to Javy.

I think Gary deserves special recognition.

Good to know you just wanted to take a shot at me then. Next time I say something stupid make sure to remind me of my youthful ignorance while agreeing with the general point of my post.

[blackthroatedwind]

Originally Posted by iamthelurker

Good to know you just wanted to take a shot at me then. Next time I say something stupid make sure to remind me of my youthful ignorance while agreeing with the general point of my post.

I was doing it out of the great love you know that I have for you.